A minor incident that could have been major on the FG trip got me thinking, and I'm now convinced I'm going to buy a pony bottle. My brand new Aeris Gyro octo started leaking, unbeknownst to me, right after I'd checked my gauge for the second time at the bottom (2200PSI); the next time I checked it (about 5 minutes later, at 75 feet or so on Stetson Bank), I had 1100PSI. I signalled my buddy, then started an ascent; I did my safety stop while swimming to the boat, and got back on with about 300 PSI remaining. I heard the octo hissing as I climbed the ladder out of the water. I knew my buddy was in the area during my ascent, and the use of her octo was a possibility, but my only thought was getting safely onto the boat ASAP. Luckily, I had the "old" one in my save-a-dive bag, replaced the Gyro right after that and never had another problem.
Another reason to be redundant is that we just had a meeting at my LDS, and a member of ERDI (Emergency Response Divers International), gave a presentation, and got me interested in that type of diving (level I); they require at least an 18CF pony (a 30 or 40 is recommended), completely detachable without assistance, either underslung or attached to a backplate or 80.
Edited by hambergler, 25 August 2008 - 08:50 PM.